The Paradoxical Art of “Inception”

Relativity-escher

M.C. Escher, “Relativity,” 1953

What is so compelling about riddles, mysteries, and puzzles?  Most people are fascinated by images and objects that are paradoxical or impossible in real life but look oddly convincing and perplexing in 2D.  Art:21 Season Four featured contemporary artists Allora & Calzadilla, Mark Bradford, Robert Ryman, and Catherine Sullivan who investigate the boundaries between “abstraction and representation, fact and fiction, order and chaos.”  Throughout history, artists have been compelled to explore paradox as contradiction, ambiguity, and truth.

hamilton-perf-001

Ann Hamilton, “kaph,” detail 1997.

The paradoxical structure of my work is often to engage that place of in-betweenness; to engage it, not to make a picture of it, not to make it its subject, but actually to try to work at that place in a way that demonstrates it, that’s demonstrative, that occupies it. You know it’s very abstract, but concrete.

Ann Hamilton

It would seem that paradox inspires artists to expand their imaginations, derive abstract concepts, and dream bigger.

Art is paradoxical by nature. It both reflects the past and creates the future. It both orders and dis-integrates, and somehow, through the course of both, defies entropy.

Maybe that’s what humans do, too: reflect and create.

Maybe that’s why we need art so badly.

Josh Allan Dykstra

The Penrose stairs is a 2D depiction of a staircase in which the stairs make four 90-degree turns as they ascend or descend yet form a continuous loop, so that a person could climb them forever and never get any higher. This is clearly impossible in 3D but the 2D version achieves this paradox by distorting perspective. The best known examples of Penrose stairs appears in a couple of famous lithographs by M.C. Escher (see top image) and this brings us to Christopher Nolan’s Inception, a film that is billed as a story about dreams but also delves deeper into our fascination with paradox.

Note that this entry is not a review of the film, nor are there any major plot spoilers for those who have yet to see the film.  I have seen this film three times on the big screen because if you want to truly understand the mechanics of Inception rather than simply going along for the ride, you need to see the film more than once and spend some time solving its puzzles and untangling its mysteries.  I had a different purpose for each viewing and spent some serious time analyzing the art (and design) in the film.

Inception-Poster1

“Inception” theatrical poster. © Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc., 2010.

‘Inception’ means the beginning or creation of something like a fantasy dreamscape or immersive installation.  Scenes in the film look like M. C. Escher’s work set in both real and alternate worlds. The plot blurs realities, captures the imagination, and invites viewers to explore our interpretations of what is real or not.  Christopher Nolan has found a way to captivate audiences using contradictory sets and defying acts of gravity that are awe-inspiring.  Several moments captured my attention and made me more aware of my own thought process regarding paradox in contemporary art.

A paradox is not a conflict within reality. It is a conflict between reality and your feeling of what reality should be like.

– Richard Feynman

The film centers on Cobb (Leonardo DiCaprio) and his team of extractors, forgers, and architects who go on missions to infiltrate victims’ minds through dreams and to steal important information.  In one dream sequence, Arthur (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) uses the Penrose stairs to show Ariadne (Ellen Page) how to disguise the boundaries of the dreams she built as a novice architect. From a certain perspective, the staircase appears to climb or descend infinitely, but look differently and you can see they cut off abruptly.  Arthur calls this “paradoxical architecture.”

inception1lg

Production still from “Inception”

Between viewings one and two, I learned that Ariadne, the architect, is also the name of a character from Greek mythology who guides Theseus, the hero, from a maze. Eames (Tom Hardy), the forger, shares his name with seminal designers/architects Charles and Ray Eames, who made the celebrated short film, Powers of Ten, about the magnitude of the universe. The name Cobb is thought to come from Jacob, who, when fleeing from his murderous brother in the biblical book Genesis, dreamed of a ladder to heaven.

You need to a flashplayer enabled browser to view this YouTube video

I was amazed at how art was used to illustrate the plot and alluded to broader concepts in our society.  In addition to the Penrose stairs (Escher), one brief scene features the torn visage of a Francis Bacon portrait on a wall.  In another scene, the face of Cobb is shown as contorted, emerging in slow motion from rushing slabs of water, like the tortured faces in several of Bacon’s famous works.  We are provided with clues to the main character’s tumultuous inner struggle.  Paradox and the dream logic of Inception pays homage to the surrealists and symbolist artists of the past.  Relatively obscure artist Austin Osman Spare (whose work is not featured in the film) developed “idiosyncratic magical techniques including based on his theories of the relationship between the conscious and unconscious self.”  Spare’s proto-Surrealist art brings to mind the twisted, sometimes grotesque art of Francis Bacon that complements the film’s plot.

inception30

Production still from “Inception”

In his book Towards an Immersive Intelligence Joseph Nechvatal, a post-conceptual digital artist and theorist writes,

For Spare, and I agree with him here, there are no “levels” or “layers” of consciousness, and no dichotomy between the “conscious” and the “unconscious.”  There isn’t even a clearly definable boundary between “consciousness” and the “object of action” and “situation.”  There is only a depth or thickness of self-awareness, from the thinnest film of near being, where we engage in pure desire/instinct driven towards action, to an opacity so paralyzingly thick that it induces catatonia.  The point of automatism is that the more spontaneously we act, the less self-conscious we are.

Inception is part of a tremendous artistic/cultural paradigm shift, or as Nechvatal calls it, a viractualist zeitgeist that “signals a new sensibility emerging in art respecting the integration of certain aspects of science, technology, myth and consciousness — a consciousness struggling to attend to the prevailing contemporary spirit of our age.”

Plus Hans Zimmer’s film score is amazing!

Contributor
Nettrice Gaskins is an artist and educator who holds a Ph.D. in Digital Media. Gaskins compiles the Magazine's "Weekly Roundup" and occasionally contributes articles on afrofuturism.
  1. Good stuff here, I really enjoyed this – thanks!

    Reply

  2. alessia says:

    thank you so much for this it was really insightful, especially the part about francis bacon since im an art student, and you wouldnt believe it but… this seems like deja vu… just recently i have been exposed to him more thoroughly and on tv they showed this documentary about his life and motifs and ideologies of life, and ive being obsessed with the notion of inception. so i cant tell you how much i loved this link that you made me aware of between the two !! thank you!

    Reply

  3. Pingback: Reader: August 4, 2010 « updownacross

  4. Nettrice says:

    You’re welcome! I’m glad you all liked this entry. I guess after seeing Inception thrice it really became clear to me that Nolan inserted these works of art purposefully, as it relates to his narrative/plot/motif. At first it seems random: Ummm…okay. It’s a Francis Bacon painting in a movie about dream thieves but the actors very clearly note it, speak about it, so you start to make connections.

    I’ve gotten other feedback from readers on Facebook and Twitter re: the Powers of Ten and the interconnectedness of it all. I guess that’s what I like most about this whole thing.

    Reply

  5. Nettrice says:

    I forgot to add that as of result of this I’m either dreaming more or paying closer attention to my dreams. Christopher Nolan apparently is really into lucid dreaming, as well. There is a purpose behind much of what he put into Inception. It’s nearly devoid of filler.

    Reply

  6. Pingback: reading list | POSTstudio

  7. Pierre Dowing says:

    As a bit of a retired artist, I’d like to share this article with you (http://www.pressdisplay.com/pressdisplay/showlink.aspx?bookmarkid=5ZNOPXBQRF66&preview=article&linkid=4e9ffa03-a6f7-432e-a7c6-285a3dceed03&pdaffid=ZVFwBG5jk4Kvl9OaBJc5%2bg%3d%3d). It’s a rarity that really speaks true to the modern artistic community.

    So if you have a bit of time, this one’s not a bad read.

    Reply

  8. Hsiang says:

    Love the movie but as an architect the film barely scratches the edge of my imagination as a designer. I do find the aspect of “sampling” fascinating. I had a conversation with a fellow architect regarding what we thought of the film and also spoke about a few built project that remind us of the dream setting in the film: http://www.ezarchitecture.com/blog/episode-13-of-ezarchitecture-podcast/

    Reply

  9. Nettrice says:

    Pierre and Hsiang: Thanks for the links.

    Hsiang: Last months I listened to immersive 3D architects and researchers Jon Brouchoud and Terry Beaubois discuss architectural practices that translate to virtual environments: http://www.metanomics.net/show/july_7_-_3d_architecture_physical_and_virtual_practice

    I especially liked the part about how real life architecture is being influenced by virtuality. I intentionally left out virtual 3D worlds, as I have already written several entries about it for Art:21 and I wanted to focus more on the art in the film (Inception).

    Reply

  10. Pingback: Inception and the Shared Dreams of the Digital Humanities | RtH: Remixing the Humanities

  11. Pingback: 10.10.10. is Powers of Ten Day « SL Art HUD Blog Thingie:

  12. Pingback: Letter from London: Frieze of Access | Art21 Blog

  13. Pingback: Welcome Back | Art21 Blog

  14. Pingback: Letter from London: The Time of Your Life | Art21 Blog

  15. Pingback: From Second Life to Microcubology « SL Art HUD Blog Thingie:

  16. Pingback: Visual Methodologies – Pt. 2 « Principles of Visual Design

  17. Sowa Mai says:

    Thanks for this well thought out and supported article. I had a great time following you down the rabbit hole of links and theory. I find myself becoming wary of the words as it seems to build up toward a catatonic thickness as referred to by Nechvatel. It is rewarding to see ones actions validated in writing but the continued exploration demands a degree of playfulness restricted by lengthy examination. I do appreciate the work you have put in and intend to view the film again with these ideas in mind. It seems Bacon had very little padding if any between his life and subconscious desires. Generally those of us who are so in touch with all parts of themselves are considered aberrations and are confined or revered depending on their societal connections. Then reverence is a form of confinement itself. Please excuse me I have an overwhelming desire to go make art :)

    Reply

    Nettrice Reply:

    Thank you Sowa and happy new year! Nechvatal can’t take sole credit for notions about cognitive space. Henri Bergson, Gilles Deleuze, Joseph Nechvatal and others posit that there are no levels of consciousness, no boundaries between consciousness or the “object of action” and “situation.” Inception challenges its audience to explore these conceptions in order to grasp the deeper levels of awareness experienced by characters in the film. We are made privy to the mapping of the main character’s (Cobb’s) memory and gain entry into a new type of narrative space where virtuality is further explicated or, depending on the viewer, complicated.

    Francis Bacon, Austin Osman Spare, Escher and some contemporary artists are more able to engender thought processes and perceptions regarding paradox, difference and virtual reality. And, yes, many are labeled as aberrations but we are still so intrigued by their contributions. Why is that? Automatism, lucid dreaming and dreamtime learning (Murngin, Wawilak of Oceania) are all part of ontology of difference that is quite ancient.

    Reply

  18. Pingback: Visual Methodologies Pt. 2 « Principles of Visual Design Spring 2011

  19. Pingback: Creative Metamedia: Augmented Reality Art Production « SL Art HUD Blog Thingie:

  20. Pingback: Field of Voices – Mobile AR Art & Performatism « SL Art HUD Blog Thingie:

  21. Pingback: It’s a Fantastic Universe… so why aren’t we outside? « SL Art HUD Blog Thingie:

  22. Pingback: The Artist is Prescient: Relational Aesthetics and Augmented Reality | Art21 Blog

  23. Pingback: Art21 2009 to the Present « SL Art HUD Blog Thingie:

  24. Pingback: Paradoxes, Puzzles & Mathematical Concepts: 3D Printed Games | Renegade Futurism

Leave a Comment

*